Fell In Love with A Girl – The White Stripes (2001, XL Records, Taken from ‘White Blood Cells’)
Points 191
Highest Position First Twice
Pretty much from the start, the Greatest W in Rock Countdown came down to two bands, The White Stripes and the band that finished first. At first the Stripes looked like they were going to walk it. At the half way stage, Jack and Meg were 18 points clear at the top, and were regularly appearing in the Top Three of nearly set of votes that came in. There was one simple reason for this, The White Stripes were incredible and when the first emerged at the turn of the century that were doing things and making sounds that no bands were making or even daring to make. Or as Middle Aged Man puts it,
“The White Stripes for a short period were the best on the planet, not only was the music amazing but their fashion sense was stunning. Although being ginger I could never wear red”.
The Same Boy You’ve Always Known – The White Stripes (2001, XL Records, taken from ‘White Blood Cells’)
It was perhaps ‘White Blood Cells’, the bands third album that saw them breakthrough amidst massive critical acclaim, the Daily Mirror for instance called them ‘The Greatest Band since the Sex Pistols’, which whilst sort of right, also suggests that the stereo in the Daily Mirrors office hadn’t been updated since the late seventies because the “greatest bands since the Sex Pistols” are in order, Modern Romance, JoBoxers, De La Soul, James, Oasis, Northern Uproar, Terris, the Strokes and then The White Stripes. Regardless, it was ‘White Blood Cells’ and the tracks on it, that won them an army of fans.
Here’s Another Jim to explain it from his perspective,
“I probably heard them first around the same time as most other people – ‘Hotel Yorba’ which blew me away and I loved them from them on – although to me they never got better than ‘White Blood Cells’ – I saw them around then and they were the closest I’d seen to the Pixies – Jack White is an incredible guitarist and front man – Meg’s drumming gets a lot of flak but sometimes it’s not about being a great drummer (which she is) but its about being the RIGHT drummer and unquestionably her drumming is right for The White Stripes (you only have to look at everything Jack’s done since and there’s nothing as consistently good as The White Stripes)”.
Hotel Yorba – The White Stripes (2001, XL Records)
If ‘White Blood Cells’ won them fans, the three albums that followed it, kept them at the top of rocks premier league. ‘Elephant’ came first and that for me is the pinnacle of the bands career. ‘Elephant’ is an astonishing record, full of great songs, incredible guitar solos (like the one on ‘Seven Nation Army’ for instance) and it contains some of Meg’s finest drumming.
Seven Nation Army – The White Stripes (2003, XL Records)
After ‘Elephant’, the band returned with a more striped back affair called ‘Get Behind Me Satan’, which despite seemingly abandoning their punky blues style for a more fresh approach, it gained them yet more critical acclaim.
The Denial Twist – The White Stripes (2005, V2 Records)
The last White Stripes album was ‘Icky Thump’ and that heralded a return to the punky garage rock that they had become synonymous for, and it gave the band a Number 2 hit in the UK, with the title track,
Icky Thump – The White Stripes (2007, Warner Brothers Records)
I’ll let The Robster have the final word on The White Stripes because I think he summed up what a lot of people were thinking at the time, especially chaps in their 30s, who were sighing and reaching for the cardigans.
“Second place goes to the White Stripes, a band who thrilled me as I turned 30, thus ensuring I didn’t slump into typical 30 something blandness where Coldplay were considered the most cutting edge band in my life”.
And so we reach the end, here is the final lyrical test.
“He’s got you back and that’s all he wants. A lot more than I’m left with”